Turkey Club Sandwich with Avocado Mayonnaise

photo (13)

Ah, Feathers the Turkey, we hardly knew ye. But for the brief time we did, you were juicy and delicious, and you looked good enough to star in a Norman Rockwell scene…and as your last contribution to our festivities, you get to be the star of the show for the ultimate use of Thanksgiving leftovers: the club sandwich.

I am not a fan of repeating the Thanksgiving feast with leftovers, which is why the club sandwich is what I do with my portion of leftover turkey. (Hell, I’m not even a fan of eating the Thanksgiving feast on the day of the holiday. While you dine at the table, I’ll be in the kitchen picking bits of turkey off the carcass and cracking a bottle of wine. All the tasting I do during the cooking process fills me up, and the anxiety of getting the meal to the table shuts down my appetite anyway. Cheers, everyone, my work here is done.)

The key to making a good club sandwich – whether you use Thanksgiving turkey or deli meat – is the technique. Thus, I give you your new club sandwich mantra: Heat the Meat. Remember this.

This sandwich uses traditional turkey club ingredients with the addition of an avocado mayonnaise. You can use regular mayo, of course, but I felt obligated to give you something a little more involved to make this blog-worthy.

Mantra ready? Let’s begin.

The Ingredients: 

For one sandwich.

For the Avocado Mayonnaise:

  • 1 Small Avocado
  • 2 Tbs. Mayonnaise – I used an olive oil mayo.
  • 1 Small Lemon – You will be using this for the juice and you will only need a very little bit. You can use lemon juice from a jar if you want. I won’t judge.
  • White Pepper
  • Salt and Black Pepper
  • Cayenne Pepper

For the Sandwich:

  • 3 Slices of Hearty Bread
  • 4 Slices of Bacon – Raw. You will cook it during the prep for the sandwich.
  • Leftover Turkey – As much as you like. Slice it as thinly as possible to make it sandwich-friendly.
  • 1 Roma Tomato
  • 1 Handful of Lettuce – I used a spring mix.
  • Avocado Mayonnaise – Ingredients above.
  • 1 Tbs. Butter
  • Chicken Broth – Just a little bit and just in case.
  • Cheese – This is optional and I don’t use it because I try not to eat a lot of dairy, and I only like to consume cheese when it makes a point in a dish. Otherwise, eh. If you want to use cheese, I recommend a white like a munster or a mild provolone. 

The Tools: 

  • Knife and Cutting Board
  • Toaster
  • Measuring Spoons
  • Small Mixing Bowl
  • Medium Non-Stick Skillet
  • Spreader
  • Fork
  • Plate with Paper Towel
  • Toothpicks

The Action:

  • Cut the avocado in half and remove the pit. Spoon the avocado meat into the small mixing bowl.
  • Sprinkle with a little white pepper and black pepper.
  • Add the mayo and mix together with a fork until blended and smooth.
  • Sprinkle a tiny bit of salt into the mixture and a 10 drops of lemon juice – I swear I am not being picky here. You just don’t want a lot at first.
  • Add a pinch – just a pinch – of cayenne.
  • Mix together and taste. Adjust the seasoning to suit your tastes. The end result should be a creamy avocado mixture with a bit of pepper and spice.
  • Set the mayonnaise aside.
  • Place 4 strips of bacon in the skillet and heat on the stove until the bacon is crisp.
  • Remove the bacon to the paper towel-covered plate and let it drain.
  • Remove the grease from the skillet leaving just a bit of residue in the pan.
  • Diagnose your turkey. You read that right. If you are using Thanksgiving turkey that was dry when you ate it the first time, then add the entire tablespoon of butter to the skillet. If your turkey was moist, add just a little bit of it. (Or if you are willing to deal with the calories and serve your penance with a long run like me, go ahead and add the butter anyway.)
  • Melt the butter over medium heat. While the butter is melting, add the turkey to the pan with a little splash of chicken stock.
  • Sprinkle the turkey with a little pepper and work it around the pan to heat up and moisten up. Don’t cook it much more than it is already cooked. Remember your mantra.

photo 2

  • While the turkey is heating, toast your bread.
  • Spread the avocado mayo on the just-toasted bread and add the turkey while the turkey is still warm.
  • Place the bacon on top of the turkey and top with tomato and lettuce.
  • Place another slice of bread on top.
  • Spread the mayo on that slice of bread and repeat the stacking of the ingredients.
  • Place your final piece of bread on top and slice into triangles. Secure each triangle with a toothpick.

photo 1


Of course, you can make turkey club sandwiches with other items from the Thanksgiving meal. Replace the mayo here with cranberry sauce and add a good sharp white cheese and you have another outstanding offering (I would leave off the tomatoes there, too.) Be creative…just remember the mantra.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s